Anastasia Beverly Hills medium brown brow product comparison

I own and love several Anastasia Beverly Hills brow products, and using them has made me interested in trying out the rest of the ABH brow line. Shopping online poses a tricky question - are all of the Medium Brown shades the same color? I love my Medium Brown dipbrow pomade, but is it the same shade as the Brow Wiz in Medium Brown / Medium Ash?

Last time I was at Ulta, I swatched the 4 ABH brow products in Medium Brown to find out.

Left to right: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Medium Brown / Medium Ash, Brow Powder Duo Medium Brown, Perfect Brow Pencil Medium Brown, Dipbrow Pomade Medium Brown
The swatches above are not over primer, picture taken in indirect natural light. Swatches are directly from the pencil or done with my finger, I did a couple of passes to show the texture.

• Brow Wiz in Medium Brown (formerly Medium Ash) - a true medium neutral brown, product is pigmented with a thin pencil nib
• Brow Powder Duo in Medium Brown - darker shade on the left is a softer version of the Brow Wiz shade, the lighter shade on the right is a light cool toned taupe, both shades are firmly pressed and swatched with multiple layers to show full opacity
• Perfect Brow Pencil in Medium Brown - shade in between both shades of the Brow Powder Duo, lighter and a little more yellow than Brow Wiz or Dipbrow Pomade, formula is harder and more waxy than Brow Wiz, standard pencil barrel size
• Dipbrow Pomade in Medium Brown - ashy, cool toned medium brown shade that is a little darker and cooler than Brow Wiz, very pigmented but less emollient cream texture than a typical gel eyeliner

If you would like to see more swatches and comparisons, I have detailed review and comparison swatches of ABH Dipbrow in Medium Brown here and swatches of ABH Medium Brown Dipbrow and Perfect Brow Pencil here. Hope this is helpful!