I love trying out affordable retractable eyeliner pencils, so I picked up 2 Jordana Easyliner for Eyes eyeliners last time I was at Walgreens. I chose Coffee Bean, a matte dark brown, and Khaki, a cool toned grey. These retail for $2.49 each.
Pros:
- Affordable automatic eyeliner pencil option
- Pretty good color selection (no nude shade)
- Emollient enough to apply smoothly, waxy enough to stay put
- Easy to tightline with - doesn't clump up in the lashes
- Transfer to the lower lashline after 6-8 hours of wear (mild to moderate)
- I don't live close to a Walgreens (have to stop in when I visit my mom)


